Parker - Wine Advocate Robert M. Parker, Jr. (98 Punkte)
The 2004 La Muse, a blend of 88% Merlot / 8% Cabernet Franc / 4% Cabernet Sauvignon, is equal parts Alexander Mountain, Knight’s Valley and Bennett Valley fruit with a tiny bit from Dry Creek. The wine grew incrementally as it sat in the glass. A dense purple color was followed by aromas of loamy soil, charcoal, asphalt, chocolate, freshly brewed espresso and abundant blackberry and cassis fruit. This deep, rich beauty is still young and primary, but is loaded with potential. Anticipated maturity: 2017-2035.
Wine Spectator (87 Punkte)
The Old and New Worlds meet in this massively structured yet agile and balanced blend, which shows aromas of black currant, fresh earth and leather, with lean flavors of blackberry, cedar and mineral that finish with chewy tannins. Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon and Malbec. Best from 2011 through 2016. 942 cases made.
Vinous Stephen Tanzer (95+ Punkte)
Bright, dark medium ruby. Medicinal black fruits, menthol, rose petal, brown spices, mocha, espresso and molten chocolate on the very ripe nose; some hints of _surmaturité. Boasts a texture like liquid velvet; not particularly sweet but delivers terrific depth of dark raspberry and chocolate flavor and an incredibly glossy texture. As seamless as this wine is, its powerful structure gives a kick to the finish, where broad, serious tannins saturate the entire palate. This very young, sophisticated wine is a beauty, but give it some time in a decanter if you plan to open a bottle anytime soon.